DisturbedAeons: The Old Library Sandbox

I believe Dark days are upon us, my brethren.
Dark days that are soon to be realized.
I've heard the walls of the Library crackling,
As if just behind them, a fire is burning.
A fire hotter than a thousand suns.
My body will lay upon your books;
Hear me, brothers: the end of the Library is coming.
A burning greater than that of Alexandria.
Greater than that of Alexandria Eternal.
The end of the library will be like nothing before it.
A Great Searing which will tear through the Library.
The Library will burn.
I heard the Rounderpede chittering with another archivist.
"Yes, just the one," it said.
"The whole Library, just for one book?" Its companion replied.
"All of it."
They know what is to happen, they know the end is coming.
The Book will be found
I just hope that there will be a Library to turn to tomorrow.
And a new order will rise.

Unfortunately, I'm gonna have to give this one a downvote. For a piece of verse, this doesn't really have any interesting imagery. The only imagery you have is "A fire hotter than a thousand suns," which itself is fairly bland and inoffensive. Not to say that a free verse poem is only good if it has interesting imagery, but this doesn't have a narrative either. It doesn't have any themes besides 'impending doom,' and that theme is told explicitly to the reader multiple times. Instead of seeing the effects of this impending doom on the narrator, we just get told repeatedly that a vague 'something terrible is coming'. The majority of this poem consists of references to events, characters and things that have not been explored here at all (or even explained/given context to).

As an introduction to a larger story, this could maybe work, but as its own page, it doesn't have any substance. I think before you start building this 'Old Library' canon, you should definitely give this some more thought: come up with interesting questions about your story, explore themes and conflicts you can inject into the story to give it more emotional weight, think of a narrative arc that would make it feel like a story. Things like that.

I also think getting it another round of crit would have really helped you realise and address these problems before posting. Something to keep in mind.

Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License